22/08/2021
Intermingled - The Wait
Survivors of Ireland’s mother and baby home institutions have now been told there will be further delays in the roll of out of the government’s planned redress scheme. The redress scheme would see victims of these institutions receive financial aid and a form of assistance with their future medical costs. The number of survivors including women and children is estimated at over 130,000. The costs of this scheme which is long-overdue for victims is rising. This has pushed the Irish Government to demand financial involvement from the Catholic church. The amount of money available to church leaders in Ireland is unclear however, property data shows the completion of a 2021 deal involving the Catholic Archdiocese of Dublin where they received €95.5 million by selling the former Clonliffe College seminary and adjoining lands to the GAA. Of the 18 homes mentioned in the controversial Mother and Baby Home report, only three of the orders who ran these institutions have said they will, or will consider being financially involved in the redress scheme. Direct payment to victims is now said to not be available until late 2022, and so they wait.
The catalyst for this elusive redress scheme came from the public reaction to the government’s official mother and baby home report. Contradictory witness reports from victims state the common practice of children being removed from their mothers and forced into illegal adoption. This information was excluded from the official report. A second report has been offered to the Irish Government by 25 experts in the field of Irish history, in this alternative report which is corroborated by victim testimony, it now states how mother and baby home residents were subjected to involuntary detention, forced labour, and illegal adoption. Victims have urged children's Minister Roderic O'Gorman to accept this report which will allow for a more balanced conclusion however, he claims he is under no legal requirement to do so.
As the true scope of these issues unfolds, its global presence is evident. In May 2021 the remains of 215 children on the grounds on one of Canada's largest indigenous schools were found. This is one of Canada's many residential schools operated by the state and The Catholic church. These substandard boarding schools existed to forcibly assimilate Indigenous children by destroying their culture and language. The discovery of this mass grave was the first of many and in stark comparison to the calls of Irish survivors. The Indigenous community leaders have called on police to lay criminal charges against the Canadian government, the Catholic Church and individual perpetrators of crimes committed in the institutions, and so they wait.
Image 1 - Tuam.
Image 2,3- News footage of churches during the public outcry in Canada.