06/06/2026
One rule: Bring evidence, not insults.
What’s the strongest argument FOR or AGAINST spray foam? 👇
Spray foam might be the most controversial product in modern construction.
Some healthy home advocates believe it’s creating indoor air quality issues, trapping moisture, and setting us up for future building failures.
Meanwhile, spray foam contractors point to thousands of successful projects, lower energy bills, improved comfort, and tighter building envelopes.
So who’s right?
The truth is probably more complicated than either side wants to admit.
I’ve inspected spray foam projects that looked fantastic.
I’ve also inspected spray foam projects that created serious problems.
What I’ve learned is that building science rarely rewards absolutes.
Products don’t succeed or fail in isolation.
Design matters.
Installation matters.
Climate matters.
Ventilation matters.
Details matter.
I’m genuinely curious where you land on this.
If you’re pro-spray foam, tell me why.
If you’re anti-spray foam, tell me why.
And if you have actual testing, field experience, research, or evidence—bring it.
Let’s see if the comments can be more building science and less internet cage match.