05/25/2026
Welcome to the fourth and final installment of this year’s Preservation Month series with . I have one more Art Deco-style building for you.
Now, 125 E. Main is pretty unassuming. I know I’ve passed by it for decades without ever really noticing it. Art Deco details are like that sometimes, especially in a downtown mostly constructed in the 1880s.
At least as early as 1887, 125 E. Main was a drug store (Photo 3). In 1900, Jacob Dick had purchased an interest in the drug store. In 1910, Dr. Charles Riley (Photo 4, look at that handsome dude) had formed a partnership with Dick. The Dick & Riley Drug Store operated until 1933, when it burned down in the large fire on that block (Photo 5). At that point, Dick retired. Riley’s obituary states that he had worked there until 1931, when he left to practice medicine in New Ross (he died of a heart attack while working there in 1937) (Photo 6). Dick passed away in 1944 (Photo 7). Interestingly enough, they both lived on West Main Street three blocks apart, and even more interesting to me, Dr. Riley rented rooms in the house I myself lived in at 311 W. Main.
Obviously, the block was not built back in a day, and in 1934 the lot was still vacant. In 1936, it was listed as the “Gt. A & P Co.,” which stood for the Great Atlantic and Pacific Tea Company. What would become the ubiquitous A&P Grocery occupied the newly built one-story Art Deco-style store. The building was significantly smaller than the previous one. It was (is) covered with buff glazed brick, had a brick geometric design, and vertical decorations at the corners of the roofline. By 1942, the A&P became a Merit Shoe store, and then even later, Kenney Shoes (Photo 8). By the 1980s (and likely well before), the original facade was covered mostly by porcelain enamel panels, which are still there today.
Let me know any memories you have of this building! Thank you for coming along with us this year!