03/22/2026
Photo printing results! ✨
It’s a long post but worth the read if you’re someone who likes to print your images 💕
For this experiment, I printed the same three images with three different companies:
• a black & white portrait
• a bright, colorful “painting session” shot
• a warm fall session image
⸻
Walgreens
The biggest pro here is convenience — same-day printing and pickup is hard to beat. But as expected, that convenience comes at the cost of quality.
Overall, the images printed noticeably darker, especially in the shadows, which caused a loss of detail. The black & white image was the weakest of the three — and also had a slight green tint, which affected the overall image.
The painting session image actually held up better than I expected and came closer to Mpix, but it still didn’t quite match the overall quality.
⸻
Shutterfly
This one surprised me the most.
Shutterfly was the only company that noticeably shifted color tones. Whites turned slightly off-white, and the overall image leaned warmer/orange. While the print quality itself was a step up from Walgreens, the color inaccuracy is something to keep in mind.
That said — their black & white print showed more facial detail than Mpix, especially around the eyes.
However, when looking at larger open areas (like backgrounds), I noticed visible horizontal print lines (pic below to show). Compared side-by-side, Mpix prints were completely smooth, which gives a much cleaner, more professional finish.
⸻
Mpix
This was my favorite overall.
Colors are closest to the true colors of the original image, the quality was consistent, and everything felt clean and professional. This is the closest match to what I deliver digitally — which is huge.
The only slight downside was the black & white image where Shutterfly showed a more facial detail. However, Mpix still wins in overall print smoothness and consistency.
⸻
Final Thoughts
This was such a fun experiment!
If I’m ordering prints, I’m choosing Mpix every time for color images.
For black & whites specifically, Shutterfly might have a slight edge in subject detail… but it’s a trade-off with overall print quality.